3 TFSA Red Flags the CRA Is Actively Looking for

2026-03-18 20:45:00 ET

The Tax Free Savings Account (TFSA) is a powerful tool for wealth creation and tax planning, yet many Canadians misuse it as a regular savings account. Maybe it’s confusion with the name or the 1% per month penalty. According to the latest data from Statistics Canada, the average fair market value of a TFSA portfolio per individual is just $33,534 in the 2023 tax year, while the cumulative contribution room is $88,000.

Common TFSA missteps Canadians should avoid

While some Canadians effectively leverage their TFSAs to accumulate over $1 million, many fail to maximize this opportunity. The concerning trend was highlighted by a TD Bank study, which found that most millennial and Gen Z account holders are not investing TFSA money. Money left idle is a depreciating asset as inflation keeps reducing the purchasing power of the dollar. Even term deposits can barely help you beat inflation.

Even if you don’t know where to invest , no-brainer TSX stocks like Enbridge ( TSX:ENB ) and Shopify ( TSX:SHOP ) are a good start. Enbridge can give you regular quarterly dividends, which could grow by 3–5% annually. While Enbridge is riskier than a term deposit, its low-risk business model has enabled it to pay increasing dividends for 30 consecutive years. Similarly, Shopify is a buy in March and sell in January stock because of its predictable seasonality.  Even if you miss out on a selling opportunity, Shopify is a long-term growth opportunity.

When contributing to a TFSA, be mindful of how you make contributions, as small slip-ups can lead to overcontribution.

3 TFSA red flags the CRA is actively looking for

Failing to report your TFSA contributions and withdrawals on your personal tax return is one oversight TFSA investors make. Your financial institutions report this information to the CRA. The CRA keeps track of over-contributions you make.  Following are more TFSA mistakes to avoid.

Mistake 1: Contributing to multiple TFSA accounts

Canadians can open multiple TFSA accounts with different financial institutions, believing they may receive a higher contribution limit. But the contribution limit is for each individual. Which means, the $7,000 limit for 2026 is the combined limit of all TFSAs in your name.

Mistake 2: Transacting between multiple TFSAs

Moving funds between TFSAs by withdrawing and redepositing can mistakenly inflate your contribution total. If you contribute $7,000 to TFSA 1 and then withdraw $3,000 and contribute that amount to TFSA 2, the CRA will count your TFSA contribution as $10,000. If you want to transfer the balance between two accounts without affecting your contribution limit, you have to ask your financial institution to do the transfer. This way, there won’t be an official TFSA withdrawal; instead, it will be a transfer.

Mistake 3: Selecting beneficiary instead of successor

Naming a spouse as a beneficiary rather than a successor has significant tax implications. You can only make your spouse your successor. A successor can transfer TFSA funds after your death without affecting their contribution room.

If you name your spouse your TFSA beneficiary, your spouse will have to transfer the contribution in the following year of the death by December 31 and file Form RC240 within 30 days of the contribution to enjoy the contribution exemption. If the account holder dies in October 2025, the beneficiary spouse has until December 31, 2026, to transfer the balance.

For beneficiaries such as children, siblings, parents, or friends, the TFSA contribution room will be used up when transferring the TFSA balance. For instance, Jay receives a $50,000 TFSA balance from his late sibling, but he only has a contribution room of $40,000 in 2026. He will have to pay tax and a 1% monthly penalty on the $10,000 surplus contribution.

Strategies to enhance your TFSA contribution without penalties

While you can contribute only up to your contribution room, you can invest more in a TFSA without incurring penalties through these strategies:

• Dividend Reinvestment Plans ( DRIPs ): Reinvesting dividends can compound growth without incurring additional contributions.
• Reinvesting Capital Gains: Retain and reinvest capital gains from asset sales within the TFSA to maintain tax-free growth leverage.

By understanding these nuances, you can transform your TFSA into a powerful tool for financial growth. Stay ahead of the curve with the latest insights and strategies on maximizing your TFSA investments by subscribing to our newsletter.

The post 3 TFSA Red Flags the CRA Is Actively Looking for appeared first on The Motley Fool Canada .

The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Shopify. The Motley Fool recommends Enbridge. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy . Fool contributor Puja Tayal has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

2026