Intuit: Sell-Off Has Reset The Setup, Time To Underwrite The Franchise

2026-05-24 03:18:30 ET

Investment Thesis

• Multiple compression has gone too far . Intuit ( INTU ) now trades at 11x my FY27E non-GAAP EPS of $28.50, against a 5-year historical forward P/E average of ~33x. The market has derated INTU to a multiple below Adobe (around 15x P/E) despite higher revenue growth (~13% vs ~9%), comparable operating margins, and a stronger free cash flow profile (~40% FCF margin). The $307 print incorporates a permanent impairment of the TurboTax franchise that the underlying numbers do not support.
• The single biggest existential risk has been eliminated . IRS Direct File was killed in November 2025 and is not returning in 2026, removing the secular tail risk that drove much of the multiple compression. The Street has not fully recalibrated for this. TurboTax is now operating in a competitive environment essentially unchanged from 2022, but the stock trades at less than half the multiple it carried then.
• The 17% workforce cut is a margin event the market is reading as a distress signal . Stripping roughly 3,000 roles at a fully loaded cost of around $200k implies $600M of gross annualized savings. If you assume that half is reinvested into AI and mid-market products, that still leaves about $300M of net opex leverage, or roughly 140 bps of margin uplift on the FY27 base. The Q3 stock reaction (-20%) priced this as if management lost confidence in the growth, not as if they simplified the cost structure ahead of an AI transition.
• Mid-market is the real growth story, not TurboTax unit volumes . Intuit Enterprise Suite and QuickBooks Online Advanced are growing north of 30% and addressing customers in the $5M-$250M revenue band that historically belonged to NetSuite, Sage Intacct, and Workday Adaptive. This is a legitimate ERP-adjacent TAM expansion, supported by a 250-person dedicated sales force and a new AI agentic feature set launched in spring 2026. If the segment grows at a sustained 30%+ growth rate, this becomes a material driver of the consolidated mix by FY28.
• Capital return at depressed prices compounds the call . The new $8B buyback authorization announced with Q3 represents more than 9% of current market cap. Executed across the next 18-24 months at an average price even 30% above today's level, that retires approximately 20M shares, or 7% of the count. Combined with a 15% dividend hike, INTU is returning capital at multiples that are historically rare for this asset.

Read the full article on Seeking Alpha

For further details see: